Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews, December 2007, p. 600-619, Vol. 71, No. 4
1092-2172/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/MMBR.00011-07
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Bioanalytics, Institute of Pharmaceutical and Medicinal Chemistry, Heinrich-Heine-University, Universitätsstr. 1, D-40225 Düsseldorf,1 Department of Molecular Biology, Max Planck Institute for Infection Biology, Charitéplatz 1, D-10117 Berlin, Germany2
SUMMARY INTRODUCTION IgA1 PROTEASE IgA1 Protease from Neisseria gonorrhoeae: Discovery of the First Autotransporter and Initial Applications Biotechnical and Biomedical Applications of IgA1 Protease-Mediated Surface Display AUTODISPLAY An E. coli Autotransporter in an E. coli Host Background Biotechnical and Biomedical Applications of the Autodisplay System Autodisplay of enzymes and whole-cell biocatalysis. (i) Hydrolases. (ii) Esterases. (iii) SDH. (iv) Bovine adrenodoxin. Autodisplay of enzyme inhibitors and library screening. Autodisplay of epitopes and vaccine development. SURFACE DISPLAY OF RECOMBINANT PROTEINS BY OTHER AUTOTRANSPORTERS PERSPECTIVES ON THE APPLICATION OF THE AUTODISPLAY SYSTEM COMPENDIUM REFERENCES
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
A universal display system must have a number of crucial features. It should pose minimal restrictions on the size and structure of the protein to be displayed. The system should utilize standard protocols in molecular biology and standard bacterial strains. Tools must also be available to analyze and evaluate the efficiency of passenger display. Optimally, the system should be simple and easy to handle to minimize unexpected obstacles. The autodisplay system has been developed to fulfill these requirements to the greatest possible extent (73). In this review, we summarize the basic structural features and the advantages of this Escherichia coli surface display system and give examples for its successful application in enzyme display, whole-cell biocatalysis, inhibitor display and design, library screening, and live vaccine development.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Secretion mechanism of the autotransporter proteins. (A) Structure of the polyprotein precursor. (B) Transport of the recombinant passenger. By the use of a typical signal peptide, a precursor protein is transported across the inner membrane. After arrival at the periplasm, the C-terminal part of the precursor folds as a porin-like structure, a so-called β-barrel within the outer membrane, and the passenger is transmitted to the cell surface. SP, signal peptide; IM, inner membrane; PP, periplasm; OM, outer membrane.
|
![]() View larger version (9K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Linear structure of the CTB-IgAβ hybrid protein, used for the first surface display of a recombinant protein with the aid of an autotransporter. SP, signal peptide; P, passenger.
|
The view that this was a host-specific phenomenon, rather than due to the recombinant passenger transported, was supported recently by investigations of the role of Omp85 in the assembly of β-barrel proteins within the outer membrane. It was demonstrated by Robert et al. (97) that the Omp85 assembly factor recognized its outer membrane protein substrates by virtue of their C-terminal signature sequences. This interaction was shown to be species specific, which is reflected by a consensus C-terminal motif identified in the outer membrane proteins of E. coli that differs from the corresponding motif in Neisseria. It could explain the inefficient assembly of Neisseria outer membrane proteins, and hence deficiencies of the E. coli autotransporter proteins, on a molecular level. Supplying the neisserial PorA with the E. coli C-terminal motif clearly demonstrated the impact of this observation, enabling the proper assembly of a Neisseria β-barrel protein in the recombinant E. coli host. Ref.
A promising biotechnical application was achieved by the surface display of the mouse MT protein using the IgA1 protease translocation unit. MTs are small cysteine-rich proteins that bind heavy metals and are produced by mice and other eukaryotic organisms. In addition to E. coli, Ralstonia eutropha (formerly Alcaligenes eutrophus) was chosen as a host organism, since its natural habitat is soil and the chances for survival in that environment are much better for this organism than for E. coli. Moreover, R. eutropha has a natural resistance to heavy metals. This resistance is mediated by a proton-driven heavy metal efflux pump. The cation/proton antiport, i.e., heavy metal efflux and proton uptake, leads to an increase in the pH in the vicinity of the cell and subsequently to the precipitation of heavy metal carbonates. Cells of R. eutropha displaying the mouse MT were used to collect Cd2+ ions from liquid media as well as for the detoxification of polluted soil. It was shown that soil contaminated with 150 µM cadmium salts strongly decreased plant growth of Nicotiana bentamiana, but after inoculation of the soil with R. eutropha cells displaying the MT protein, this negative effect on plant growth was countermanded (130). Further improvements are required before cells displaying MTs can be used for bioremediation of soil contaminated with cadmium; however, two important observations can be derived from this pioneering work. First, cell engineering protocols developed for E. coli for the surface display of recombinant proteins can be transferred to other species, including those having their natural habitat in extreme environments. Second, the IgA1 protease translocation unit is heterologously applicable, since it was demonstrated that the surface display of MT was possible not only in E. coli and R. eutropha (130) but also in Pseudomonas putida (131), another natural soil inhabitant. This supports the original idea proposed after expressing the Neisseria IgA1 protease polyprotein precursor in E. coli (35, 92) and later in Salmonella (56), i.e., that this transport mechanism was the paradigm for all gram-negative bacteria. Transport of the protein was facilitated by simply transferring the precursor protein gene from the natural to the heterologous host. The precursor contains sufficient structural information for surface translocation, and no cofactors are required. More recent investigations appear to indicate the involvement of additional proteins or chaperones in the autotransporter secretion pathway (86, 126, 133). Taking these results together, the initial conclusion could be modified to say that any additional proteins or cofactors required for autotransporter-mediated surface display of passenger proteins can be provided at least by a variety of different species if not by all gram-negative bacteria. Autotransporter proteins can be considered to be distributed ubiquitously throughout all genera of the Alpha-, Beta-, Gamma-, and Epsilonproteobacteria and in the phylum Chlamydia.
The fusion protein constructs consisting of recombinant passenger proteins and the IgA1 protease translocation unit were also used for investigations on the mechanism of surface translocation in E. coli. It was found that the purified translocation unit formed a ring-like oligomeric complex consisting of at least six monomers in the outer membrane with a central cavity of about 2 nm in diameter (138). It was hypothesized that the transport of the passenger domain to the cell surface proceeds through this oligomeric ring shaped by the translocation unit monomers. This hypothesis made autotransporter translocation to the cell surface similar to the mechanism proposed previously for fimbrial ushers or secretins (127) and countermanded the concept of protein translocation through the β-barrel pore of a single translocation unit. The formation of such a superordinate ring-like structure would lead to a larger lumen than that formed by a single β-barrel and would explain other findings from the same group. Using different single-chain antibody constructs in combination with the IgA1 protease translocation unit, it was demonstrated that folded passenger proteins containing stable disulfide bonds were able to be transported to the cell surface (136, 137). In contrast, superordinate ring-like structures have not been observed for the translocation unit of any other autotransporter protein, in particular those investigated in the natural host background (81). Moreover, conductance measurements with the translocation units of NalP (87) and BrkA (109) in black lipid membranes indicated a smaller pore size than that expected if oligomeric ring-like structures were formed. We propose a different explanation that accommodates all of these somewhat controversial observations. The clearly detectable oligomeric rings and the definite transport of folded domains could be an extraordinary feature of the Neisseria IgA1 protease translocation unit expressed in an E. coli host background. That the host background can have severe effects on the structure of an autotransporter protein has been exemplified by the Helicobacter pylori AlpA autotransporter. AlpA was shown to be processed as a lipoprotein when expressed in E. coli DH5
, but no such processing was observed in wild-type H. pylori (85). Not only the passenger and the translocation unit but also the signal peptide and the inducible promoter were heterologous in relationship to the E. coli host cell. The PelB signal peptide used with the IgA1 protease translocation unit was not a natural constituent of the passengers under investigation, and the inducible promoter used to express the artificial constructs resulted in much more protein in the cell than observed for the IgA1 protease in a natural environment. In the initial experiments using the IgA1 protease translocation unit and CTB as a passenger, the CTB signal peptide was used for transport across the inner membrane and a constitutive promoter was applied to express the different gene constructs (49, 56, 58). This could explain why oligomeric ring-like structures were not observed in these experiments and why it was necessary to avoid disulfide bonds to keep the passenger in a translocation competent state. Even though it is conceivable that the high-level expression of an autotransporter in the heterologous host could result in the formation of oligomeric aggregates, it is rather unlikely that this would result in an alternative export mechanism. A plausible explanation for the proposed translocation of folded domains (136, 137) could also be that the integrity of the outer membrane was damaged under the experimental conditions used, resulting in the artificial accessibility of the passengers to the cell surface. Finally, the hypothesis of ring formation by usher proteins has since been modified, and it is currently accepted that usher proteins act as dimers based on recent investigations (68).
The host background is not the only influence on surface display of recombinant proteins using translocation units from different autotransporters. The structure and the nature of the (recombinant) passenger domain itself, as well as the signal peptide used for inner membrane translocation and the degree of expression induced by the promoter, can strongly influence the results obtained. It appears worthwhile to reconsider the extrapolation of results obtained with more or less artificial systems to the situation found for a natural autotransporter protein in its natural environment.
|
|
|---|
We have developed a system for the autotransport of recombinant passengers to the cell surface, which we call the autodisplay system. Autodisplay initially described only the system based on AIDA-I, but there is currently no reason why display systems based on other autotransporters should not also be called autodisplay. We propose that autodisplay should be defined as the recombinant surface display of proteins or peptides by means of an autotransporter in any gram-negative bacterium.
The β-barrel and linker region of AIDA-I was used in the development of the autodisplay system and combined in frame with the signal peptide of CTB and a strong constitutive promoter (PTK) within a medium-copy-number plasmid backbone (73). The signal peptide, promoter, and plasmid vector backbone were identical to those used in the initial experiments investigating surface display by the IgA1 protease autotransporter (55, 56, 58). This provided a better basis to compare the efficiencies of the two surface display systems. PTK is an artificial promoter that was constructed for IgA1 protease-mediated surface display (56). A schematic description of the structure of a typical artificial autotransporter protein used for autodisplay is shown in Fig. 3. The dimensions of the β-barrel of the AIDA-I polyprotein precursor were initially assessed by computer-aided structure prediction (73) and then experimentally verified by investigating the subcellular locations of the identical passenger fused to various portions of the C-terminal part of AIDA-I (74). The minimal linker portion required to reach the cell surface was determined to be 52 amino acids (aa) (73). This minimal linker was used for the surface display of short peptides or proteins with no known fixed three-dimensional structure and for peptide libraries (45). A more extended linker was used for proteins, such as enzymes, where limiting the flexibility could constrain folding and consequently activity (47, 50, 107) (Fig. 4). The linker was extended to the length corresponding to the linker of the natural AIDA-I passenger, which is 160 aa long (124). Protease cleavage sites have been inserted into the linker regions used for autodisplay, to enable the sequence-specific release of the passenger protein into the supernatant. Epitopes have also been inserted to allow detection of the tag via monoclonal antibodies. An antibody-independent detection method, requiring only the addition of a single amino acid, was developed for autodisplay and named "cystope tagging" (46, 51). This is superior to the epitope-tagging strategy, in which 5 to 10 amino acids must be inserted. Cystope tagging is based on the fact that in gram-negative bacteria natural surface proteins, including autotransporters, contain no accessible cysteine residues. The insertion of a single cysteine residue into the linker region (Fig. 3) provides a site for modification, for instance, by maleimide and its derivatives. This specific labeling can be used to detect and verify surface exposure by Western blotting, photometric, or FACS applications (46). Specific labeling of a single cysteine residue within the linker region was shown to work even if the passenger protein contained several cysteine residues (51). This may be because cysteine residues are generally buried and not externally accessible in native proteins such as enzymes. Cystope tagging was successfully applied to follow surface translocation of bovine adrenodoxin (Adx) (five inherent cysteines) (46), sorbitol dehydrogenase (SDH) (three inherent cysteines) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (50, 51), and esterase (two inherent cysteines) from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (51).
|
View larger version (8K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Structure of an artificial autotransporter protein as used in autodisplay. FP-CT is a cysteine-containing fusion protein that is encoded either by plasmid pSH4 under control of a strong constitutive promoter (PTK) or by plasmid pET-SH4 under the control of the inducible T7/lac promoter. The environments of the passenger insertion site, necessary to obtain surface translocation, are given as sequences. Restriction endonuclease cleavage sites for insertion of passenger-encoding DNA sequences are underlined. Various other restriction sites are available in similar plasmids. The signal peptide originates from CTB, and the signal peptidase cleavage site is marked by an arrow. The signal peptides of PelB, AIDA-I, OmpA, and β-lactamase have also been used in combination with translocation units from different natural autotransporter proteins. The specific cleavage site for IgA1 protease that can be applied for the release of the passenger protein into the extracellular milieu is in italics, and the linear epitope for a mouse monoclonal antibody (Dü142) which can be used for labeling is in bold. The cysteine used in "cystope tagging," a specific labeling and detection method, is indicated by a black box.
|
![]() View larger version (74K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Passenger-driven dimerization of SDH expressed by autodisplay at the cell surface. Due to the free motility of the β-barrel, serving as an anchor within the outer membrane in autodisplay, passenger proteins can spontaneously form dimers at the cell surface, even when they are expressed as monomers form monomeric genes. This is aided by the high number of recombinant proteins (e.g., SDH) expressed at the cell surface by autodisplay, bringing the monomers in close enough vicinity to interact. It is a unique feature of the autodisplay system and has not been reported for any other surface display system so far.
|
To summarize, the autodisplay system consists of vectors encoding various artificial autotransporter genes using different parts of the linker region and the β-barrel from AIDA-I. The autodisplay system is highly flexible for application-based adaptation. This flexibility is provided by different modifications of the linker, use of various signal peptides under the control of inducible or constitutive promoters, and mutant strains of E. coli supporting transport and surface display by the autotransporter pathway. Methods for detection and tracing of surface translocation are also available, which are independent of the protein domain used as the passenger.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Autotransporter-mediated surface display of recombinant proteins and peptides in gram-negative bacteria
|
(i) Hydrolases. The β-lactamase hydrolase was the first example of the surface display of an active enzyme by autodisplay in E. coli (65). The β-lactamase protein occurs naturally in the periplasm, confining the challenge of its autodisplay to the last step in transport, the outer membrane translocation (18, 63). Testing the surface display of a naturally occurring periplasmic protein had the additional advantage that its native signal peptide could be used. Considerable amounts of β-lactamase were detectable at the cell surface in the OmpT/DsbA-negative host background. The enzymatic activity was determined to be 0.1 to 0.2 U per 2.5 x 109 bacterial cells using penicillin G as a substrate and was estimated to be approximately 20% of the activity of purified, free β-lactamase. The cell integrity remained undisturbed, indicating a clear advantage of autodisplay for the surface expression of β-lactamase over other display systems in E. coli (25). These experiments were performed with cells harvested from agar plates as in earlier experiments using the IgA1 protease. We should point out here that the use of solid growth media is not a hindrance in basic research but would be impractical for biotechnical applications.
(ii) Esterases.
Among the hydrolases, esterases represent a group of enzymes of great interest for biotechnological and industrial applications (14, 88). They exhibit a broad natural variety of substrates and reaction types. Due to their diverse substrate specificities and their stereoselectivity, esterases have been successfully used in the synthesis of optically pure substances. More recently, esterases have also been used in laboratory approaches to obtain tailor-made biocatalysts (94, 95, 105). It is of striking advantage in the evolutive approach to express the enzyme to be evolved on the surface of a living cell. The first esterase that was autodisplayed in an active form on the surface of E. coli was EstA from Burgholderia gladioli (107). EstA consists of 351 aa and has a molecular mass of 35.4 kDa. Its coding sequence was inserted between the signal peptide of CTB and the full-length AIDA-I linker region. After detection of the esterase domain on the cell surface, the specific esterase activity of whole cells on the substrate, p-nitrophenylacetate, was determined to be 1.7 mU/mg protein. The enzyme activity of whole cells displaying EstA was determined photometrically using an agar plate pH assay in combination with a filter overlay assay employing
-naphthyl acetate as a substrate. This methodology provides an option for the high-throughput screening of enzyme libraries. The viability of E. coli cells displaying EstA was not reduced, as measured by the number of CFU. This is a clear advantage of the heterologous surface display of esterases by autodisplay over other systems, in which only 15 to 60% of the CFU were reported, depending on the heterologous esterase displayed (4). Autodisplay could be employed for the surface display of other heterologous esterases (51); however, more recently autotransporter proteins have been discovered which possess an esterase moiety as the natural passenger (66, 144, 146). These proteins may provide, at least in some instances, a simpler method to exploit the synthetic potential of an esterase enzyme displayed at the cell surface.
(iii) SDH. Polyols and sugars are awkward to produce by standard organic synthesis because of the enhanced number of identical functional groups at different positions in these molecules. Biocatalysis using enzymes with high regio- and stereoselectivity could afford a solution (30). For this purpose, SDH from Rhodobacter sphaeroides was expressed on the cell surface using autodisplay (50). SDH belongs to the short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase family of proteins and is a dimer with a subunit molecular mass of 29 kDa (257 aa) (90, 120). Although sorbitol is the preferred substrate, SDH can also utilize other substrates, including the conversion of galactitol into D-tagatose and of L-arabinol into L-ribulose (103). By inserting its coding sequence between those of the CTB signal peptide and a modified linker region, SDH was successfully expressed at the cell surface using autodisplay. In fact, SDH expression exceeded that of the resident outer membrane proteins, OmpF/C and OmpA. Antiserum specific for SDH recognized a protein band twice the size of monomeric SDH in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under nonreducing conditions (without 2-mercaptoethanol). This was a clear indication for the passenger-driven dimerization of monomeric SDH subunits at the cell surface (Fig. 4). This passenger-driven dimerization is a unique feature of autodisplay and has not been observed for any other surface display system to date. SDH has been reported to be a functional dimer as a purified enzyme (90, 120). Based on the absence of interactions fixing the β-barrel to lipids within the membrane, the β-barrel may be assumed to be mobile within the membrane bilayer. Since the AIDA-I β-barrel, which serves as the membrane anchor of the passenger in autodisplay, is mobile within the outer membrane, passenger-driven dimerization or even multimerization should be possible on the E. coli surface. The whole-cell biocatalyst obtained by autodisplay of SDH was used for the efficient synthesis of sorbitol (0.11 U/2.5 x 109 cells), fructose (0.11 U), D-tagatose (0.07 U), and L-ribulose (0.15 U) (50). The number of SDH molecules per cell was determined to be 150,000 by specific fluorescein labeling of the SDH molecules on the cell surface and comparing FACS analysis to a calibration curve using beads coated with known numbers of fluorescein molecules. The specific activity of SDH molecules displayed at the cell surface was compared to that of free SDH molecules purified after intracellular expression (120). The specific activity of surface-displayed molecules was only 5% of the activity of free molecules. A similar, although smaller, reduction in activity was observed for β-lactamase. Aside from the reduced molecular flexibility resulting from C-terminal fixation of the enzymes to the linker region, another situation may further reduce enzyme activity in the case of SDH. Many of the lipopolysaccharide (LPS) molecules comprising the outer part of the asymmetric outer membrane are similar to the natural substrates and products of SDH reactions. Competitive enzyme inhibition of SDH oxidoreductase by these molecules could contribute to the reduced enzyme activity. It was also determined that the substrate preference of the surface-displayed SDH was altered in comparison to that of free, purified SDH. Purified SDH preferred sorbitol as a substrate in the oxidation reaction, followed by galactitol and finally arabitol, whereas the whole-cell biocatalyst preferred arabitol, followed by sorbitol and galactitol (50). Both limited flexibility due to linker attachment and competition by LPS molecules probably act in concert to influence the functionality of surface-displayed SDH. We should also point out that folding of the enzyme molecule on the cell surface happens in the absence of chaperones and folding catalysts. Within the cell, protein folding is assisted by chaperones, which prevent misfolding and aggregation. It cannot be excluded that a considerable part of the molecules displayed at the cell surface will misfold in the absence of such chaperones. The absence of folding catalysts, such as DsbA and peptidyl-prolyl cis/trans isomerases, could also hamper efficient folding of displayed proteins and contribute to reduced enzyme activity.
(iv) Bovine adrenodoxin. The ferredoxin from bovine adrenal cortex, termed adrenodoxin (Adx) (14.4 kDa), belongs to the [2Fe-2S] ferredoxins, a family of small acidic iron-sulfur proteins that are found in bacteria, plants, and animals (31). It plays an essential role in electron transport from adrenodoxin reductase (AdR) to mitochondrial cytochrome P450 enzymes, which are involved in the synthesis of steroid hormones. The iron-sulfur cluster of Adx is coordinated by four sulfur atoms from the side chains of four of its five cysteine residues (80). During heterologous nonsurface expression in E. coli, it was shown to be assembled in the cytoplasm as well as in the periplasm (36). Autodisplay of Adx was successfully achieved using the CTB signal peptide and the AIDA-I linker and β-barrel (47). Expression was of the same order of magnitude as that observed for the natural outer membrane protein, OmpA, in the same cell. As observed for SDH, dimeric Adx molecules formed spontaneously with high efficiency on the bacterial cell surface (44). Adx was previously reported to function as a homodimer in electron transfer (91). The dimeric Adx molecules at the cell surface, however, were inactive, and electron spin resonance measurements revealed that they were devoid of the iron-sulfur cluster (47). Since the autotransporter secretion mechanism requires that a protein be transported to the surface in an unfolded state, Adx was transported as apo-Adx without the prosthetic group. The apo-Adx molecules displayed at the cell surface were subsequently activated by the chemical incorporation of the [2Fe-2S] cluster. Iron-sulfur cluster incorporation appeared to work best under anaerobic conditions, when Li2S was added dropwise to Adx-displaying cells in a ferrous ammonium sulfate buffer at room temperature. Using this procedure, iron-sulfur clusters were formed and incorporated into the apo-Adx displayed at the bacterial surface. Cells survived the procedure well and could be handled afterwards under aerobic conditions without a reduction in activity (47). Subsequent addition of purified AdR and P450 CYP11A1 or P450 CYP11B1 yielded a whole-cell biocatalyst for the efficient synthesis of pregnenolone from cholesterol or of corticosterone from 11-deoxycorticosterone (Fig. 5) (44). Addition of artificial membrane constituents or detergents, which was indispensable in the past for functional steroidal P450 enzymes, was unnecessary. The whole-cell biocatalyst activity (0.21 nmol/h/nmol CYP11A1) was, however, in the same range as that obtained using artificial membrane or detergent systems. Together the results show that whole cells expressing functional Adx molecules on the surface provide a sufficient and more natural environment for P450 enzyme functionality. The whole-cell system developed by autodisplay of Adx is an easy-to-handle and stable tool for the expression of membrane-associated P450 enzymes without the need of microsome preparation or reconstitution of artificial membrane vesicles. Harnessing the biotechnological potential of P450 enzymes is substantially improved by this methodology. As one example, E. coli cells expressing Adx at the surface could be supplied with P450 and AdR and then could serve as a whole-cell carrier to target soil requiring detoxification. Cells prepared likewise could also be used in a fermentor to synthesize steroids or produce pharmaceutically important secondary metabolites from plants or microorganisms. Laboratory evolution could also be simplified, as cells can easily be harvested by centrifugation and, if necessary, distributed in separate reaction chambers. The question arises whether P450s expressed on the E. coli surface by the autotransporter pathway could also be active, especially if they are coexpressed with Adx.
![]() View larger version (54K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Whole-cell biocatalyst for the synthesis of steroids obtained by autodisplay of Adx. After transport of apo-Adx to the cell surface, dimers were formed spontaneously and the electron transfer activity of Adx was restored by chemical incorporation of the [2Fe-2S] cluster. After the addition of purified AdR and CYP11A1 or CYP11B1, an efficient whole-cell biocatalyst for the synthesis of pregnenolone or corticosterone, respectively, was obtained. The cell envelope of E. coli provided a membrane environment sufficient for both P450 enzymes to be active. OM, outer membrane.
|
The question arises whether the E. coli cell envelope is actually capable of incorporating such a tremendous number of recombinant proteins. If we assume for the following theoretical considerations that a single E. coli cell is a 1-µm-wide and 5-µm-long cylinder (Fig. 6A), the complete surface area of the cell can be calculated to be approximately 17.2 µm2. The actual length of an E. coli cell, of course, depends on the growth phase and nutrition state and could be in the range of 2 µm for exponentially growing cells. The actual value of the surface area could also be somewhat higher than that of a cylinder, since the E. coli surface is assumed to be crumpled, thus increasing its area. The pore size of the NalP β-barrel was determined to be 10 x 12.5 Å from its crystal structure (133). The overall β-barrel of the AIDA-I autotransporter was calculated according to the method of Murzin et al. (82, 83) to have a radius of approximately 1.1 nm (J. Jose and S. von Schwichow, unpublished). Assuming an equal distribution of the 180,000 Adx molecules detected on the cell surface over the entire cell surface area, the mean distance between two barrels is estimated to be about 8.4 nm in any direction (Fig. 6B). The E. coli cell envelope should have no problem incorporating this number of recombinant proteins and, in principle, should be capable of absorbing more than four times this number. The mean distance of 8.4 nm between barrels within the outer membrane has another interesting implication. The lateral diffusion coefficient for membrane proteins in fibroblasts at room temperature was determined to be 2.6 x 10–10 cm2 s–1 (23). There is no experimental evidence that lateral diffusion rates in the fibroblast plasma membrane and the bacterial outer membrane are comparable. However, using this value for the lateral diffusion of a β-barrel within the outer membrane of E. coli, it would take less than 34 µs to bring two barrels into contact by accident. It appears reasonable that Adx dimers form spontaneously from the monomers fused to the AIDA-I β-barrel on the cell surface, using this estimation for diffusion (44). This estimation can be taken as only a rough approximation, since the lateral diffusion coefficient for membrane proteins, which usually contain
-helices, in the fibroblast plasma membrane is not exactly transferable to the β-barrel proteins within the outer bacterial membrane. The lateral diffusion coefficient of LPS in Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium was experimentally determined to range between 2.0 x 10–10 cm2 s–1 (104) and 2.9 x 10–13 cm2 s–1 (79). Recent investigations point out that the determination of these values was strongly influenced by experimental conditions, such as the LPS chain length or the fluorescent dye used to monitor movement (29). Nevertheless, using lateral diffusion coefficients in this range for a β-barrel protein within the outer membrane, two passenger proteins anchored within the outer membrane by a β-barrel would still only need much less than 1 second to meet. Interestingly, the investigation of LPS diffusion (29) showed that, at least in growing cells, proteins are not evenly distributed on the E. coli cell wall but are organized into helical ribbons that span the length of this gram-negative rod. The LPS O antigen especially appeared to be virtual immobile within these helical ribbons, indicating the existence of stable lateral interactions between tightly woven LPS molecules. Four forces can be taken into account for this high degree of organization: interconnection of LPS molecules by divalent cations, hydrogen bonding, interactions between the O polysaccharides of neighboring molecules, and van der Waals attractions between fatty acid chains. Although free diffusion of LPS was hampered by these interactions, no mechanical obstacles appeared to hamper protein diffusion into broad areas of the walls or the poles of the cell. It was suggested that diffusible proteins were not part of stable helices formed by LPS. Although the view of an E. coli outer membrane comprised of a homogeneous surface with evenly distributed LPS molecules, phospholipids, and an abundance of proteins has changed to a membrane displaying areas of distinct composition, the accidental concourse of two single proteins within this surface still appears to be an event of high probability which should occur within a very short time frame.
![]() View larger version (36K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Distribution of the β-barrels within the outer membrane of E. coli by the use of the autodisplay system. (A) The rod-shaped cell of E. coli can be idealized as a cylinder with a height of 5 µm and a radius of 0.5 µm. with these values, the entire surface area of a single cell can be calculated to be 17.2 µm2. (B) The number of active Adx molecules displayed at the surface of a single cell using autodisplay has experimentally been determined to be 180,000. The radius of a single β-barrel can be calculated to be 1.1 nm, which is in congruence with the value derived from the crystal structure of NalP (1.0 nm in one dimension and 1.25 nm in the other). Given that the barrels are evenly spread over the entire surface, the mean distance between two adjacent molecules can be calculated to be 8.4 nm in any dimension by assuming that the expansion space of one barrel has the shape of an equilateral hexagon. (C) E. coli cells displaying 180,000 Adx molecules were subjected to indirect immunofluorescence microscopy. After labeling with an anti-Adx rabbit serum and a second anti-rabbit antibody coupled to FITC, cells were analyzed, and no indication was found for a polar distribution of recombinant Adx molecules on the cell surface of E. coli as has been reported for the natural passenger of AIDA-I. Rather, the picture obtained accords with an even distribution all over the entire surface.
|
Autodisplay allows a tremendous number of active molecules (>105 per cell) to be displayed on the cell surface without hampering cell viability. This result is unprecedented and unique among all other bacterial and surface display systems applied so far. Furthermore, autodisplay provides novel and efficient access to the very interesting synthetic potential of the membrane-associated P450 enzymes. Adx autodisplay was also the first report of the cellular surface display of a recombinant, heterologous protein with an inorganic prosthetic group.
Autodisplay of enzyme inhibitors and library screening. A unique feature of the autodisplay system is its application as a tool in drug discovery (45). This challenging application is basically comprised of three steps: (i) surface display of peptide libraries, (ii) labeling of single cells with an inhibitor structure by target enzyme binding, and (iii) selecting and sorting of labeled cells by FACS (Fig. 7). The rationale of this concept is based on the idea that a typical enzyme inhibitor has a high affinity for its target enzyme and vice versa. The inhibitor-target enzyme affinity can be exploited to specifically label E. coli cells displaying an active inhibitor at the cell surface. If the enzyme is coupled to a fluorescent dye, flow cytometry can be used to sort single cells expressing an inhibitor with affinity for the enzyme. The selected cells can subsequently be used for clonal production of cell quantities sufficient for analytical or preparative purposes. This concept takes advantage of the high copy number of each molecule expressed on the E. coli cell surface using the autodisplay system and of the good viability and integrity of these cells. The first advantage enhances the selection of positive from negative variants, and the latter is crucial for the number of clones surviving the FACS sorting (45).
![]() View larger version (33K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. Surface display library screening to identify new enzyme inhibitors by autodisplay. (1) A peptide that is known to be an inhibitor (the lead) is expressed at the cell surface by autodisplay and tested for functionality. (2) Random libraries are generated by standard genetic engineering tools, where each cell of E. coli displays one distinct variant in high numbers. (3) The library of E. coli cells with different variants is screened by target enzyme labeling. Since an enzyme inhibitor has high affinity to its target enzyme and as a consequence the enzyme has high affinity to the inhibitor as well, the target enzyme will bind to an inhibiting structure expressed at the cell surface. If the target enzyme is coupled to a fluorescent dye (e.g., FITC), the cell displaying the appropriate variant can be sorted by FACS. (4) The cell selected by this procedure can be used for clonal production of cell quantities sufficient for, e.g., DNA sequence analysis and hence for the identification of a new lead structure.
|
A protease inhibitor with a less stable three-dimensional structure, P15, was investigated as a model inhibitor in autodisplay (45). P15 consists of 15 aa and is derived from the human C-reactive protein, whose serum concentration increases during acute inflammation. It has been shown to be a strong inhibitor of human cathepsin G, with a Ki of 0.25 µM (147, 148). Cathepsin G is assumed to be an important target in the treatment of chronic inflammatory diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis or pulmonary emphysema (98). Cathepsin G was also reported more recently to activate matrix metalloproteinase 2 (108), which plays an important role in tumor invasion. P15 could be expressed in larger amounts than aprotinin on the E. coli cell surface by autodisplay (45). The expression level was in the same range as that of the resident OmpA outer membrane protein, and cells displaying P15 could be efficiently labeled with human cathepsin G coupled to fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC). This second example of a successful target enzyme labeling of cells displaying an inhibitor could be easily quantified using FACS (45). Moreover, cells displaying P15 could be sorted from a mixed population with an excess of control cells displaying a noninhibiting peptide. The selected cells survived sorting without loss and were grown to single-cell clones to be used for DNA sequence analysis and studies on protein expression. Autodisplay of an enzyme inhibitor with subsequent target enzyme labeling and FACS is a reliable method to sort cells displaying an active inhibitory structure at the surface. This method was subsequently used to screen a random surface display library consisting of 1.15 x 105 different variants, and three new peptide inhibitors of cathepsin G were identified. The most active inhibitor was P6, with a 50% inhibitory concentration of 11.7 µM (45). Using P15 and cathepsin G as a model inhibitor and target enzyme, respectively, a new labeling procedure by fluorescence coupling of the target enzyme was developed, which is the essential element for drug discovery using autodisplay. Using repeated cycles of surface display of random libraries and FACS of positive clones, a gradual optimization that is congruent with the idea of directed evolution is possible. Autodisplay may be a promising tool for performing laboratory evolution to improve the inhibitory potential of peptides. This strategy can probably be applied for inhibitors of enzymes other than proteases or for the investigation of any receptor-ligand relationship, but further experiments to test these potential application areas will be needed.
Autodisplay of epitopes and vaccine development. In addition to the surface display of enzymes and enzyme inhibitors, the cellular surface display of epitopes and antigens is a promising application of autodisplay. The Nef epitope of the human immunodeficiency virus was one of the two initial passenger proteins expressed in the autodisplay system (73). In earlier studies concerning whole-cell vaccine development, it was shown that the secretion of antigens resulted in an improved immune protection compared to that with intracellularly expressed antigens (34, 39, 43). It can be extrapolated that the autodisplay of epitopes could result in enhanced stimulation of the immune system and that epitope autodisplay could be used to generate live oral vaccine vectors as vaccine carriers. T-cell epitopes of Yersinia enterocolitica heat shock protein 60 (HSP60) have been expressed on the surface of attenuated Salmonella vaccine strains (64) and E. coli strains using autodisplay and the unmodified AIDA-I autotransporter (61). T cells isolated from mice immunized with Salmonella cells displaying HSP60 exhibited an antigen-specific proliferation which was accompanied by high-level gamma interferon secretion. This indicates an effective immune stimulation by the vaccine strains orally distributed to C57BL/6 mice and demonstrates the applicability of autodisplay of antigenic determinants for live attenuated Salmonella vaccine strain development. E. coli cells displaying epitopes of HSP60 could be used to directly stimulate antigen-specific T-cell clones from mice immunized with HSP60 in an in vitro assay. AIDA-I-mediated surface display could also be applied for the B subunit of the heat-labile enterotoxin of E. coli (LTB), another antigenic determinant (61). More recently, autodisplay was used to express antigenic urease fragments from Helicobacter pylori on the surface of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium vaccine strains for the subsequent oral immunization of specific-pathogen-free female BALB/c mice (96). This resulted in a significant reduction in the H. pylori burden after challenge infection and an increased protective efficacy in the murine Helicobacter infection model. Taken together, these results indicate that autodisplay increases the immunogenicity of recombinant antigens expressed on oral live vaccine strains, and they show the feasibility of immunizing against H. pylori with Salmonella vaccine strains displaying T-cell epitopes by autodisplay.
|
|
|---|
More prominent examples of the biomedical and biotechnological application of cells with autotransporter-mediated surface display of recombinant proteins have been reported for MisL from Salmonella and EstA from P. aeruginosa. MisL was used for the surface display of the 4-aa immunodominant B-cell epitope (Asn-Ala-Asn-Pro [NANP]) of the circumsporozoite protein from Plasmodium falciparum. Surface display of the epitope was demonstrated in Salmonella serovar Typhimurium as well as in S. enterica serovar Typhi, and a significant immune response was obtained from immunization of mice with either live vector (100). In a follow-up investigation, two passengers consisting of either 8 or 53 repeats of the NANP tetrapeptide were constructed, and efficient surface display and the release of the passenger proteins were shown in Salmonella and E. coli (99). Another group demonstrated the surface display of a variant containing eight NANP repeats by MisL in the isogenic ler (LEE-encoded regulator) mutant of E. coli (recombinant EPEC [rEPEC] O103:H), which was shown to be attenuated and immunogenic in mice. Using an identical strategy for the surface display of the Shiga toxin B subunit (Stx1B), however, did not result in significant protection of rabbits after inoculation with rEPEC mutant cells bearing this construct (150).
The use of lipases for the hydrolysis of racemic esters is a well established method for obtaining enantiomeric pure compounds. Lipases have the ability not only to hydrolyze but also to synthesize many different esters with high specificity and regio- and enantioselectivity under mild conditions. For these reasons, they represent biocatalysts of strong interest for pharmaceutical, organic chemistry, and biotechnological applications. The EstA lipase from P. aeruginosa was used as a system for the surface display of different lipases, including LipA from Bacillus subtilis, cutinase from Fusarium solani pisi, and S. marcescens lipase (4). In contrast to other attempts for the surface display of enzymes, the EstA domain was not replaced by the various lipase domains within the polyprotein precursor in this system. Here, the recombinant lipases were inserted in front of the EstA domain, and the serine residue in the active site of EstA was changed into alanine using site-directed mutagenesis in order to distinguish between the lipolytic activities of EstA and the passenger lipase domains. This strategy would have resulted in relatively large proteins to be transported and displayed at the cell surface. All fusion constructs with the recombinant lipase domains were detectable at the cell surface and exhibited significant enzymatic activities. However, the viability of the cells displaying the different lipases was strongly reduced, as only 60% of the S. marcescens lipase cells, 30% of cutinase cells, and 15% of LipA cells survived in comparison to control cells. The reduced cell viability in these experiments may have resulted from the uncommonly large size of the displayed proteins, as well as the use of the PhoA signal peptide and the heterologous host background (a Pseudomonas gene was expressed in an E. coli host background). Nevertheless, if cell viability could be improved in this system, it could provide an interesting platform for the directed evolution of this important biocatalyst class of lipases, especially if used in combination with high-throughput readout systems for selecting improved variants (3).
|
|
|---|
A second striking advantage of the autodisplay system is the mobility of the β-barrel serving as an anchor for the recombinant protein within the outer membrane. This enables passenger proteins, which are expressed as monomers within the context of the autodisplay system, to form functional dimers at the cell surface, as observed for the autodisplay of Adx and SDH (47, 50). Such a passenger-driven, spontaneous dimerization of surface-exposed domains has not yet been reported for any other surface display system investigated. Theoretically, the stable dimers of Adx and SDH on the cell surface after autodisplay could have been formed via a dimerization of the β-barrel as well. However, dimer formation was never observed for proteins known to be monomers inherently after expression at the cell surface by autodisplay, and more recent cross-linking experiments with the AIDA-I β-barrel indicated that it is present primarily as a monomer and not as a dimer or oligomer (81). Taking these results together, it appears rather unlikely that dimerization at the cell surface is driven by the β-barrel. Passenger-driven dimerization offers interesting prospects for future applications of the autodisplay system. Other interesting proteins known to be functional as dimers, such as eukaryotic receptors or transcription factors, could be displayed in an active form at the cell surface of E. coli. The system could also be used for the surface expression of heterodimeric proteins by expressing each monomer as a single fusion with the domains needed for autodisplay in the same cell. The two artificial genes needed in this case could be carried either by one plasmid or by two plasmids belonging to different incompatibility groups. Formation of the heterodimers at the cell surface should appear spontaneously, as observed for the homodimers of Adx or SDH. Finally, the present point of view does not exclude the possibility that higher degrees of association, such as trimers, tetramers, or even hexamers, could be obtained at the cell surface using the autodisplay system. This possibility is under current investigation.
Another outstanding characteristic of the autodisplay system is the possibility of incorporating an inorganic prosthetic group into an apoprotein expressed at the cell surface of E. coli, as was successfully reported for the [2Fe-2S] cluster of bovine Adx (44, 47). Cells displaying the apoprotein were subjected to a one-step, single-vial procedure under anaerobic conditions and could be subsequently used under aerobic conditions without loss of cell viability or electron transfer activity. The functional surface display of proteins requiring inorganic cofactors has not been reported for any other surface display system to date. Autodisplay may have promise as a method of functional surface display of other proteins containing cofactors, such as P450 enzymes, flavin adenine dinucleotide, flavin mononucleotide, or metal ion-containing proteins. More experimentation with each specific target will be required before these goals can be realized. In particular, heme-containing P450 enzymes would be of great commercial importance, as they are involved in the synthesis of a wide variety of valuable compounds and the degradation of numerous toxic compounds (12). It is worth emphasizing that in the whole-cell biocatalyst for the P450-mediated steroid synthesis obtained using autodisplay of Adx, the cell envelope of E. coli provided a membrane environment sufficient for functional P450 enzymes (44). The P450 enzymes are innate membrane-associated proteins (12). Autodisplay of P450 enzymes could open a new dimension in the development of whole-cell factories, with the aim of using enzyme-coated cells for applications, including P450-mediated drug metabolism studies.
Finally, the most convenient feature of autodisplay is that surface expression of large numbers of recombinant proteins does not reduce cell viability or integrity (45, 47, 50, 73). Cells survived challenging analytic approaches, including FACS. This distinction enables selection of single cells having a specific feature from a library of variants and clonal expansion for sequence determination or structural analysis of the molecule displayed at the cell surface. This strategy was successfully applied for the identification of new cathepsin G inhibitors from random peptide libraries and is a first indication that the high number of molecules displayed on the surface of a single cell combined with persistent cell integrity could afford direct selection of cells displaying the correct molecules from a library (45) instead of requiring enrichment or panning positive cells (13, 142). Currently, random libraries of esterases have been successfully created and expressed at the cell surface using autodisplay (J. Jose et al., submitted for publication). The surface display library construction using autodisplay could even be extended to combinatorial approaches which take advantage of the ability of dimer formation of peptides or proteins displayed at the cell surface.
The autodisplay system has proven to be an efficient tool for the surface display of a wide variety of recombinant proteins in E. coli and perhaps generally in gram-negative bacteria. To date, its applications span the functional surface display of enzymes, enzyme inhibitors, and antigens or receptors; the development of whole-cell biocatalysts or biofactories; and peptide library screening by target enzyme binding. Future experiments will focus on its further application for analytical or preparative purposes. The heterologous nature of the artificial gene construct may influence the efficiency of protein expression at the cell surface using the autodisplay system (Fig. 3). However, these obstacles exist for any other surface display system investigated so far as well, and therefore autodisplay can be considered an attractive tool for the surface expression of recombinant proteins.
|
|
|---|
The second important issue in the surface display of recombinant proteins by the autotransporter pathway is the use of the signal peptide. The signal peptide guides the first step in transport, the crossing of the inner cytoplasmic membrane. The natural signal peptide of the autotransporter protein was used in only a few of the cases described here (16, 61, 114). The most frequently used signal sequences or leader peptides were those of CTB (22, 44, 46, 47, 49-53, 55, 56, 58, 64, 65, 73, 74, 96, 107) and PelB (pectate lyase B) (61, 130, 131, 134-138). The leader peptide of CTB had proven value in the initial experiments investigating IgA1 protease-mediated surface display of recombinant passengers (56, 58), which led to its use in similar experiments with other autotransporter proteins. Its successful use for the functional surface display of eukaryotic passengers and passenger proteins normally localized in the cytoplasm confirmed its suitability. The PelB leader peptide is included in commercially available vectors and has been extensively used in the phage display of recombinant proteins (121). PelB is a natural protein of the periplasm and, as such, presents a good alternative for cell surface translocation studies using autotransporters, because transport across the inner membrane would be facilitated by its own leader peptide and should not be a problem. The periplasmic proteins MalE (66, 101, 125), PhoA (125), β-lactamase (146), and pseudoazurin (112) have been investigated in the context of their own signal sequences but with different autotransporters. Signal sequences that were used with other passenger proteins include those of PhoA (4), of the E. coli LTB (100), and of OmpA (74). The signal sequences of OmpA, MalE, PhoA, and PelB have been reported to target the Sec pathway. Nothing is known about the CTB signal peptide in this respect. From its primary sequence, it appears to more closely resemble the signal peptides that are known to target the SRP pathway, such as Sfm or TolB. Interestingly, this is also true for the LTB signal sequence used with the MisL autotransporter. Recent studies of the unusually long signal sequences of different natural autotransporters have revealed that they could target either the Sec or the SRP pathway, depending on the conditions and their sequence content (89, 126), and that some of the proteins bearing such signal sequences exhibit preferred expression at the cell poles (42). It must be assumed that the signal sequences contain more information than simply what is needed for traversing the inner membrane. Again, this is of no importance as long as the desired biotechnical or biomedical task is fulfilled, but it can be relevant if the knowledge gained using the artificial constructs in the surface display of recombinant proteins is extrapolated to the natural situation.
Two other domains contribute to the effectiveness of the surface display of recombinant proteins by the autotransporter pathway, the linker and the β-barrel. All computer-aided approaches predicted that both termini of the β-barrel are located on the same side of the membrane, namely, on the inner surface directed towards the periplasm. Indirect experimental evidence was gathered subsequently for this (74), and final proof came from the first crystal structure of an autotransporter protein (133). Because of this conformation, a stretch of amino acids that penetrates the barrel channel and affords full surface exposure of the passenger domain is required. This sequence was determined to comprise 52 aa in the AIDA-I autotransporter using protease accessibility studies (73). The crystal structure of NalP showed this structure to consist of 32 aa and to exhibit an
-helical structure (133). This helix, which is located in the primary sequence N terminal to the barrel domain, positions the C terminus of the passenger domain at the extracellular surface of the outer membrane. Different names are used for this sequence in the literature, including the
-domain, β2-domain, linking region, or simply helix. As it links the passenger domain with the β-barrel, the name "linker" was chosen in the initial experiments with the IgA1 protease and has been used for this reason in this review. Whereas the designation of the linker region in the surface display of recombinant proteins is quite simple because it is the region linking the recombinant passenger with the β-barrel, it is much more difficult to identify in natural autotransporter proteins. For those natural autotransporter proteins which are proteolytically cleaved, whether autoproteolytically or not, and released into the supernatant, it appears to be justified to refer to the remaining portion of the protein anchored within the outer membrane by the β-barrel as the linker region. For natural autotransporter proteins displayed on the cell surface, it is a nontrivial task to distinguish between the so-called passenger domain and the linker region. Evidently, the
-helix located in the lumen of the β-barrel is an inherent part of the linker region, but in most cases, the linker region appears to reach beyond the
-helical passenger domain. It is questionable, though, whether allocating a "junction region" (86) will help to better define the boundary of the linker region.
The 52-aa region that has been shown experimentally, for the AIDA-I autotransporter, to be the minimal length of the linker to run through the hydrophilic pore formed by the β-barrel (73, 74) is sufficient for the surface display of recombinant peptides (45) and permits the folding of complex structures (52). Recent investigations revealed the presence of an intramolecular chaperone domain within the region between the β-barrel and passenger in BrkA (86), AIDA-I (62, 101), and other autotransporter proteins (38). No homologous domain has yet been identified in any other protein different from autotransporters, with the exception of some bacterial toxins. It appears not to be necessary for the surface display of functional recombinant proteins by the AIDA-I translocation unit. It can, however, in at least some recombinant passenger proteins, considerably improve the yield of surface display (74), which may be critical for certain biotechnological applications. It could be important for folding after transport or maintenance in an unfolded state during transport to the cell surface and could have coevolved with its natural passenger domains. BrkA and AIDA-I belong to the group of unusually large autotransporter proteins, which could require the involvement of an autochaperone. Therefore, a more systematic approach could unearth the truth about this particular domain in the function of the autotransporter-mediated surface display. For instance, one could conceive of using an identical (large) passenger domain with an identical signal peptide and β-barrel within the context of the same promoter and vector copy number but altering the size and primary structural features of the linker. Similar experiments could be conducted to more closely assess the other domains involved, including the signal peptide and β-barrel, as well as the passenger gene sequences utilized. Such investigations may help to unify the controversial results obtained in different investigations of the transport or nontransport of folded domains. A third concept involves an outer membrane helper protein, Omp85, in outer membrane translocation during the autotransporter secretion (87, 139, 140). This hypothesizes that the β-barrel containing the
-helical linker in its channel could be the structure at the end of the process and not necessarily imply that the passenger was transported across the channel as well, leaving the door open for folded protein translocation (87).
Finally, relatively few data are available concerning the structure-transport activity relationship of the β-barrel in the surface display of recombinant proteins. Only a few site-directed mutagenesis or deletion experiments have been performed (66, 74). As a crude rule, it is preferable to use the translocation unit within a homologous host species background, such as an E. coli autotransporter within an E. coli host. The use of an autotransporter in a species that is phylogenetically not closely related to its natural host, such as using a Pseudomonas autotransporter in an E. coli host (4) or a Neisseria autotransporter in E. coli (138), can interfere with cell viability or outer membrane integrity, whereas the use of the closely related Salmonella as a host organism with an E. coli autotransporter is obviously unproblematic (54, 64, 96). E. coli is not, a priori, an optimal host organism for any application. Pseudomonas or Ralstonia species could be much more robust host organisms for the surface display of enzymes or binding proteins for antipollution applications (130, 131). In these cases, it appears worthwhile to investigate whether a homologous autotransporter protein (i.e., a Pseudomonas autotransporter in a Pseudomonas host background) could be beneficial. Even though some details remain controversial and require further thorough investigation, the concepts concerning the surface display of recombinant proteins by the autotransporter pathway are clear, and the successful examples of their biotechnological and biomedical applications promise exciting developments in the near future.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»